MakeupTalk.com: makeup, beauty, skin care, beauty product reviews, beauty products, eyemakeup, eye makeup, hair care, talk and gossip for women


Product Review Center (16425 reviews)

Makeup Eyes - Mascara N.Y.C

Overall Average Rating 3

100% would buy this product again

Makeup Eyes - Mascara N.Y.C Lenghtening Mascara- $1.99

Review on:
Eyes - Mascara N.Y.C Lenghtening Mascara

Reviewed by: citre on 05-16-2008
More Reviews By citre

I bought this mascara because It was recommended to me buy a friend. I had never bought this kind before, because I always wanted volume. I have used their thickening mascara, but it never had done anything for me. I had nevr thought to ever try lengthening mascara. I am so glad my friend recommend this too me. I AM in LOVE! This mascara is definitely one of my HGs! It gave me super long lashes! I did about three coats, and I was pleasantly suprised that it added a little volume and lots of length. It didn't smudge or smear either! At $2 a pop, how can you afford NOT to buy this mascara?

Pros: Length, No Smudge
Cons: Not too much thickness

Review this now | (permalink)

Makeup Eyes - Mascara N.Y.C Curling Mascara- $2.99

Review on:
Eyes - Mascara N.Y.C Curling Mascara

Reviewed by: paurasmith on 04-01-2007
More Reviews By paurasmith

my eyelashes won't hold a curl for a damn (even with a lot of eye lash curler use!) so I'll try anything that says, "curling mascara"

And as a curling mascara this one bites it big time, it barely curls at all! (it's probably just my lashes though they're stubborn)

As a regular mascara though I really like it! It's a good black shiny colour. But as a curling mascara it's OUT!

Pros: black shiny colour
Cons: won't hold a curl for me!

Review this now | (permalink)

Makeup Eyes - Mascara N.Y.C Lenghtening Mascara

Review on:
Eyes - Mascara N.Y.C Lenghtening Mascara

Reviewed by: Mz LaLa on 02-02-2004
More Reviews By Mz LaLa

I have found a new mascara that I consider my HG, but this is a nice mascara and I would definitly purchase it again if I ever needed to. I bought this on a whim and was very surprised. I don't really need any lengthening on my lashes so it didn't do much for me in that department, but it did a good job of just emphasizing my lashes and making them look lush w/o flaking or smuding thru out the day. Just what I'm looking for.

Pros:
Cons:

Review this now | (permalink)